Does Mata Signing Mean Liverpool Impotency?

Souce: Wikipedia

Source: Wikipedia

With the recent signing of Juan Mata to Manchester United kicking off a reported late January splash in the transfer market, I ask the question of whether it should be of concern that a seventh place club could outspend one of the current top four in the Premier League.

Certainly not for the likes of Manchester City who seem to be able to sign whoever they wish, and certainly not for the likes of Chelsea who simply poach other club’s transfer targets at will.

Arsenal seem to refuse any acknowledgement that their side would benefit from new signings, but they never seem to lack the ability to sign who they prefer.

So that leaves only Liverpool.

My question here simply is whether or not Manchester United signing Juan Mata, and possibly more, should cause concern for a club like Liverpool in the fourth and final position for Champions League qualifications.

In past transfer windows, Liverpool have always made it clear that they will not be pressured into a panic buy, or simply to buy a player because of the transfer window being open.  Does this logic standup as the current window looks set to close?

I argue, no.

I understand Liverpool do not want to overpay for players whose clubs’ evaluation may exceed that of theirs.  However, if overpaying now seems to be an unwanted luxury, wouldn’t it be a necessity if they miss out on Champions League football?

Chelsea ended up paying 11 million pounds, one million less than requested from Basle, as the club evaluated the player at 12 million.  Liverpool were asking for around 7 or 8 million, according to their evaluation.  If a player like Salah is 3 or 4 million more than Liverpool’s evaluation during the January transfer window, how much will he fetch during a summer transfer window with no Champions League football in the club’s future, from Liverpool?

So I continue my argument by saying that Liverpool’s transfer policy is not realistic where it concerns the current transfer market, or any future transfer market.  I realize the funds may not be available, but where it concerns signing a player like Salah, who could provide immediate impact, matching Chelsea’s resolve may have pushed Liverpool ahead in the standings if not secure a top four finish based on current form.

Bringing my analysis back to Manchester United and Juan Mata …. shouldn’t it be a concern to everyone at Liverpool, if a seventh placed club can outspend your two previous transfer windows with one single purchase of a player?

Perhaps that is the financial reality in world football today?  I do not think anyone expects to match the financial power of clubs like Man City or Chelsea or PSG, Real Madrid/Barcelona.  If Liverpool don’t compete now, and by now I mean in the next three days, they will regret this opportunity even more if they don’t manage to place in the top four of England’s Premier League at the end of the season.

If that doesn’t create urgency at the club than I don’t know what will, because Luis Suarez won’t stand for it, the fans won’t stand for it, and from a historical perspective, it’s difficult to say whether a player like Mohammed Salah would ever be interested in playing for the Reds at all.

More is at stake for Liverpool in this single transfer window than maybe how they finish the season.

Liverpool FC Issue Statement Over Alleged Racial Abuse At Anfield

Liverpool FC issued a statement addressing the alleged incident of racial abuse directed at Oldham player Tom Adeyemi during the third round FA Cup win on Friday. Adeyemi, on loan from Norwich, appeared to take offense from something yelled from the stands on the KOP end of Anfield. He later gave a statement to the police claiming he was racially abused twice by a supporter.

Liverpool FC earlier today issued a statement that mirrors earlier reports that the Reds have begun working with police to launch an investigation.

“Liverpool FC apologises for upset and distress suffered by Oldham player Tom Adeyemi; the Club reaffirms commitment to work with game’s ruling bodies to fight discrimination, and the Reds vow to take strongest possible action against unacceptable behavior.”

No arrests have been made, but Liverpool FC did go on to state that they have begun working with police to begin investigating the incident.

The incident came fresh off of alleged racial abuse on the pitch between Liverpool forward Luis Suarez and Manchester United defender Patrice Evra. Luis Suarez was later found guilty of alleged racial abuse and given an eight match ban, which the player has already started serving.

News of racial abuse popping up within short occurrence of this very public incident at Anfield should not be a surprise to anyone. For years FIFA, the governing body of soccer, has been dealing with this issue in stadiums all over the world. Initially launching anti-racism campaigns with notable support from the players.

It would seem as though that the anti-racism campaign initiated by FIFA, for the most part, had been rather successful over the years. Incidents like the one between Suarez and Evra happened at a greater frequency in the past with little to no retribution for the victim. Clearly that isn’t the case anymore and with such swift and direct punishment handed down by the English FA in the Suarez case, it proved to define the commitment of national federations to address this very destructive issue.

However, I feel that where there are seeds and water to grow, any public or societal problem can be given life. I feel that FIFA’s campaign has been pushed a step back by the heavy hands of the English Premier League. Was the anger directed at Adeyemi more from frustration that Suarez’s punishment was perceived as unjust by Liverpool supporters? Was this simply an isolated incident?

Hardly. I feel that although through great efforts by FIFA to banish racism from football stadiums or the game as a whole, they have done little to address the players actions on the pitch. I fear that very high profile cases such as the Suarez ruling and the impending case against John Terry have given light a problem that may not have been perceived to exist.

Their are programs to address many different issues facing professional athletes in sport today. I feel that it has finally become time for a national federation to institute a program that brings awareness to racial abuse on the pitch as well. Such programs are often done behind close doors with the players specifically. Often teaching life strategies both on and off the pitch. I don’t see how racial abuse or racism is any different.

I believe the English FA has neither the want or the need for this type of publicity, especially after their very public failure to secure a World Cup bid. Liverpool FC was right to issue a statement today expressing their desire to work with the authorities to bring the perpetrator to justice. It’s time for the governing body to help prevent racial abuse from happening anywhere from anyone involved with the game.

Powar Urges FA To Charge Liverpool

Powar Urges FA To Charge Liverpool

I can’t say this hasn’t been a very messy affair for Liverpool FC and it continues to be dragged out in the media. Since the accusations came from Patrice Evra that Luis Suarez racially abused him, our common reaction was that it would be settled behind close doors.

Possibly with a judgement in favor of not shining the spotlight on the Premier League as a league which is apathetic to racial abuse. I think the Italian Seria A is the dubious owner of that title.

I find it hard to sympathize with the plight of Liverpool, simply because of their staunch defense and outright activism toward their support to Suarez. The now infamous shirt wearing episode the Liverpool players participated in before a match against Wigan Athletic was probably the awakening of the 500 pound Gorilla in the room.

What Liverpool FC did wrong from the beginning was claim that Luis Suarez was not a racist. We here in America are all very familiar with the fact that being a racist is totally seperate from racially abusing someone.

Had Liverpool simply admitted his behavior was incendiary this whole situation could have been alleviated with an apology. The actions of the players, the manager and the organization represented a childish response to a very serious accusation which ultimately came off as something otherwise motivated. It is dually noted that society loves a scapegoat, and right now it’s Liverpool FC, not Luis Suarez.

Luis Suarez has had a rather colorful past with on field incedents but I do not think in any way is he a racist. I just think he is petulant and somewhat childish and in the heat of a match used some rather abusive language of which he had no idea the ramification of his actions.

Be that as it may, there is no excuse at all for his behavior. So my suggestion is this Liverpool: make amends by sending Suarez out in the community for some very public service and have him work with others addressing this very toxic issue. Secondly: the owners should make a public appearance at this point and issue a very public apology.

That is the Liverpool FC I know! YNWA ….

Andy Carroll Linked with Exit in January Transfer Window

Carroll camp ‘astonished’ by Anfield exit talk

I can’t say I don’t totally agree with this on many levels. What’s important is the context of the transfer away. Does it mean permanent transfer or loan deal?

Personally I would like to see him loaned out because he was worth way too much trouble, financially and for the organization as a whole. We expected Andy Carroll to have the same scoring rate as Luis Saurez for two reasons: One, we underestimated Luis Suarez …. and two, we overestimated Andy Carroll.

Andy Carroll is nowhere near the player he was the last time he played Manchester City in a Liverpool shirt. Maybe we were quietly reserving our expectations leading up to the recent loss to the citizens, but we were all collectively hoping for a breakout game at the same time.

I still have faith in the boy, but I fear that his time on Merseyside has come to an end. Liverpool cannot wait for this player to develop at the expense of the league title and Champions League ambitions. Not to mention the fans …..